oschinanet

Monday, August 21, 2023

[New post] Objectivity in Wine Tasting—it’s a matter of degree

Site logo image Dwight Furrow posted: "Sharp disagreements among wine experts about the virtues of a particular wine are common.  One critic thinks a wine is flabby and disjoint; the other thinks it is superb. Is there a way to settle such a dispute or are we forced to say there are two differ" Exploring the Philosophy of Food and Wine

Objectivity in Wine Tasting—it's a matter of degree

Dwight Furrow

Aug 21

wine criticism 5Sharp disagreements among wine experts about the virtues of a particular wine are common.  One critic thinks a wine is flabby and disjoint; the other thinks it is superb. Is there a way to settle such a dispute or are we forced to say there are two different, yet permissible ways of experiencing the same wine?

One thing we know is that some of what we experience in a wine is a response to objective properties of the wine. We smell grassy, herbal aromas in Sauvignon Blanc because of pyrazines (among other compounds); vanilla because of the presence of ethyl vanillate, etc. The perceived weight on the palate is a function of extract, residual sugar, and or alcohol. When we taste we can fail to discern those objective properties. Novice wine tasters have trouble discerning flavor components in wine just as you might fail to taste the hint of rosemary in a sauce until someone points it out to you. All of this is well-established by science.

It is of course true that we can be misled and seem to taste something that isn't there. This is common when blind tasting in a group where comments by others may influence someone to misidentify the features of a wine. Furthermore, we can be influenced by price, reputation, expectations, personal relationships, emotional commitments,  etc. in ways that mislead us.  But this is not evidence that wine tasting is subjective—in fact quite the opposite. If there is such a thing as real expertise in identifying the properties of a wine, then it must be possible to get it wrong.  If tastes were entirely subjective there would be no right answer to the question of whether chocolate ice cream tastes of chocolate.  No one really thinks that. The fact that expert wine tasters get it wrong so often is evidence that wine tasting is harder than identifying the presence of chocolate—not that it is subjective.

So tastes are not so entirely subjective that our experiences of them have no relationship to an object.

However, each of us are biologically different to a degree and we each have a unique tasting history and a set of expectations based on that history from which there is no escape. We can't step outside our past and taste something independently of its influence. So the taste of wine (or anything else) is partly dependent on objective features of the world and partly dependent on how our view of those features has been shaped by past experience and our biology. The crucial question then is how much of a distorting lens are those factors. Does they lead us to lose touch with the world or not? This is where systematic learning, the constant calibration of one's taste to well-established standards, and a disciplined focus on getting things right comes into play. Prejudices can be overcome and influences can be identified and prevented from having a distorting influence if one works at it. And the more knowledge you have about wine regions, vinification processes, etc. the more you can use that knowledge to shape your tasting experience to conform to objective properties of the wine.

The fact that some people after years of study are able to pass the very rigorous "Masters of Wine" program is evidence that tasting expertise is real—they are not consulting oracles or hallucinating their answers.

But none of this entails that there is a final, authoritative answer to questions such as whether the 2009 Haut-Brion is superior to the 2005. Objectivity in matters of taste is a matter of degree. We can through disciplined practice learn to overcome some of our prejudices, but there is no escaping some biological differences and there is no escaping personal history. An objective judgment is one that as much as possible tells us more about the object than it does about our peculiarities as individuals. All judgments will reflect some of those peculiarities but if the judgment allows us to more fully grasp the nature of the object the judgment is reasonably objective.

What is most misleading are the terms "objective" and "subjective". Our language suggests any judgment must be one or the other. But in fact all judgments are a matter of degree—more or less objective or subjective. Part of what makes wine tasting fascinating is that it is a complex mix of objective judgment and subjective impression.

Comment
Like
Tip icon image You can also reply to this email to leave a comment.

Unsubscribe to no longer receive posts from Exploring the Philosophy of Food and Wine.
Change your email settings at manage subscriptions.

Trouble clicking? Copy and paste this URL into your browser:
http://foodandwineaesthetics.com/2023/08/21/objectivity-in-wine-tasting-its-a-matter-of-degree/

WordPress.com and Jetpack Logos

Get the Jetpack app to use Reader anywhere, anytime

Follow your favorite sites, save posts to read later, and get real-time notifications for likes and comments.

Download Jetpack on Google Play Download Jetpack from the App Store
WordPress.com on Twitter WordPress.com on Facebook WordPress.com on Instagram WordPress.com on YouTube
WordPress.com Logo and Wordmark title=

Automattic, Inc. - 60 29th St. #343, San Francisco, CA 94110  

at August 21, 2023
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest

No comments:

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

[New post] All or Nothing

...

  • [New post] Vaccination push for Saskatchewan Métis citizens
    Daniel Labbe posted: "In efforts to increase the vaccination uptake amongst the Métis community in Saskatchewan, an initiat...
  • [New post] Canada takes Olympic bronze in men’s 4×100-metre relay
    Daniel Labbe posted: "Canada has won the bronze in the men's 4×100-metre relay at the Tokyo Olympics. The team included...
  • [New post] Other news
    Pam Vernon posted: " Miscarriages, Birth Defects, and Infertility data for 2021 When those mandates end, what next? S...

Search This Blog

  • Home

About Me

oschinanet
View my complete profile

Report Abuse

Labels

  • 【ANDROID STUDIO】Displaying Toast Message With ViewModel and LiveData Room Data Persistence Library
  • 【ANDROID STUDIO】Life Cycle Scope
  • 【ANDROID STUDIO】Live Data Builder
  • 【GAMEMAKER】homeing missle shots
  • 【GAMEMAKER】Slot Machine
  • 【JavaScript html 】implements random QR code verification
  • 【JavaScript html 】sliding verification
  • 【JAVASCRIPT】automatic lock screen function with local storage
  • 【JAVASCRIPT】Mask or clip the image on canvas and move it
  • 【JAVASCRIPT】Read CSV file with File API
  • 【PYTHON】Read and Write into text
  • 【Visual Studio Visual Csharp】Ping
  • 【Visual Studio Visual Csharp】Print
  • 【Visual Studio Visual Csharp】Safe Mode Detection
  • 【Visual Studio Visual VB net】Ease of Access Center
  • 【Visual Studio Visual VB net】Orginize IE Favourites
  • 【Visual Studio Visual VB net】Unplug Eject Hardware
  • 【VUEJS】simple shopping cart

Blog Archive

  • September 2023 (1221)
  • August 2023 (1235)
  • July 2023 (1282)
  • June 2023 (1219)
  • May 2023 (1224)
  • April 2023 (1306)
  • March 2023 (1129)
  • February 2023 (1126)
  • January 2023 (1541)
  • December 2022 (1480)
  • November 2022 (1293)
  • October 2022 (1275)
  • September 2022 (1165)
  • August 2022 (1278)
  • July 2022 (1400)
  • June 2022 (1264)
  • May 2022 (1218)
  • April 2022 (1186)
  • March 2022 (1138)
  • February 2022 (964)
  • January 2022 (1162)
  • December 2021 (1709)
  • November 2021 (3135)
  • October 2021 (3259)
  • September 2021 (3140)
  • August 2021 (3243)
  • July 2021 (3255)
  • June 2021 (3144)
  • May 2021 (761)
  • April 2021 (17)
Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.